BEACH HOUSE
BLOOM
ORIGINAL RELEASE DATE: MAY 14TH 2012
1YRON’S TOP 52 RECORDS OF 2012 RANKING: #22
Much of the divisive attitude towards Beach House’s fourth record “Bloom” centred around the question of just how much longer a band could keep pushing a sound that effectively remains unaltered not just throughout the whole record in question but across all their previous records. For some, this ‘lack of progression’ from such a singular record as 2010’s “Teen Dream” would’ve been forgiven were it not for the massive critical and commercial gushing that it acquired upon its release. Hype, it seems, works very well for this Baltimore duo. What gives both sides to these arguments actual weight is the sound of the music to an uninitiated, outside source. There’s vocalist Victoria Legrand’s vocals which can be taken as soulful and caressing or downright bland and waning. Then there’s the music, a concoction of looped synths and shimmering guitars that ruminate in the most circular of fashions, intent on conjuring an internal tornado from the thick layers of sound so lovingly sculpted by their two creators. To some, this is even more unbearable than Legrand’s vocals. Believe me when I say that in the past year since Beach House truly broke big, I’ve heard as many compliments as I have disses.
As is often the case I can see both sides of the argument. “Bloom” gets off to a winning start with lead single “Myth” and the even more spectacular “Wild.” Whether you’re delving into expansive, wall-of-noise epics such as “10 Mile Stereo” or the domestic lullabies of “Holy Dances” and “Wedding Bell,” Beach House have always sounded best through headphones. “Bloom” is no different and for all its failings, these guys have succeeded in sculpting another sound world through which you can enter and quite safely become absorbed in. “Quite safely” is the key phrase in that sentence, since “Bloom” quickly descends into a place where everything begins to sound like something we have already heard before. “The Hours” and “New Year” remain the standout tracks on the middle-latter part of the album yet are surrounded by songs that seem to meander aimlessly. The problem with “Bloom” is that, while sounding great on that initial play, repeated listens actually do nothing to warrant an extended interest. Unlike some who have suggested that more time spent with “Bloom” reveals its layers, that it essentially ‘blooms,’ I found myself overwhelmingly enthralled this time last year only to quickly lose interest when I realised that many of these songs don’t really go anywhere.
Perhaps I’m being a little too critical of a band who have found a brilliant formula within the dream-pop landscape and who are essentially mining it for all it’s worth. Within that landscape there is no doubt that Beach House are the progenitors. Dream-pop as we’ve come to know it is a sound that encompasses a wide range of bands from all over the world and from all different backgrounds, yet no one has had quite as much crossover appeal as Beach House. One issue I have with Beach House is that they can quickly put me on a downer. As beautiful and ethereal as this music is, there’s something inherently despairing in Legrand’s vocals that came about with the release of “Teen Dream”. On “Devotion,” she radiated warmth with a compassion that compelled us to grab a cup of coffee and curl up by the fire as snow fell outside the window. It was romantic on a number of levels. On “Teen Dream” and “Bloom,” she’s out there in the snow and it’s an often inhospitable place to experience for the listener, too. I personally found more to explore in Wild Nothing’s superb “Nocturne,” released towards the end of the year, a record that delivers a similar dream-pop sound to Beach House but with more focus on melody and rhythm. Jana Hunter, lead vocalist of Lower Dens (another Baltimore based group), sounds similar to Legrand but is pushing her vocals into much more interesting places. Last year’s excellent sophomore album “Nootropics” is evidence of her ability to distort time passing with her subliminal phrasings. Beach House are generally excellent at what they do. It’s just that what they do now needs some serious fine-tuning.